Wednesday, November 18, 2009

Is this a Joke?

.
Sites like the Writer Beware Blogs and Writer Beware have been around for ages, doing an excellent job, warning wannabe published writers about the countless scams that try to cash in on their dreams.

The last thing I ever expected to see was an established publisher with a long publishing history - in this case Harlequin - jumping on the bandwagon of getting money from wannabe writers for what up until now was pretty much a scam. (Note: I do not consider PoD books a scam, and I see nothing wrong with getting your unpublished book printed for the benefit of friends and family. What I don't like is outright scams that encourage writers to believe they are getting something else for their money: a published book they will see in a bookshop.) I think what Harlequin is offering is sailing very close to scam territory.

And if that wasn't bad enough, this turns up: fork out 20,000 USD and let's see what you can get as a book trailer, apparently to entice genuine film makers to your book, complete with a spam email campaign? If it was anything except a reputable publisher, I would be screaming: 'Scam, scam!!'

Please Harlequin, tell me this is not associated with you.
.

3 comments:

Nyssa said...

What...the....freak?! Because authors just have $20k sitting around?

And they call it a grooming ground for emerging authors. Seriously, what is going on? Has the world gone mad? Authors should be groomed as writers. Vanity press does nothing for them. If they pay full price, they get 'editorial reviews' but they've already paid the money, so what are the 'editors' going to say?

*mumble grumble grr*

Jo said...

The sad thing is that some, not yet established, authors will be so desperate they will try anything.

Satima Flavell said...

Harlequin isn't the only company doing it either. Pretty soon we could see all publishers passing on their rejects to POD outfits and taking a cut of the proceeds. It wouldn't be so bad if only they porvided editing services so the standard is reasonable, but sadly, this is probably never going to happen.